the Economic
Environment
updated 2007 May 28, (Sept 25th, added section on income distribution, aging population, education)
see also  witiger.com/internationalbusiness/4xCdnDollarissues.htm
 
INTRODUCTION "Understanding the economic environments of foreign countries and markets can help managers predict how trends and events in those environments might effect their companies' future performance there." Daniels

The purpose of discussing the Economic Environment is to give the student an understanding of some of the ways you can understand changes in the environment and how these changes influence your decisions - ie. the dollar going up or down effects how much you can afford to import a component part from a particular country.

A part of the economic environment is the changes in the value of a country's currency. We have a special unit on the Canadian dollar exchange rate at
 www.witiger.com/internationalbusiness/4xCdnDollarissues.htm

.
In a number of international business textbooks an example of rapid changes in the economic environment is the establishing of McDonalds in Moscow after the period of Glasnost and its effect on the Russian economy.
http://www.mcdonalds.com/countries/russia/russia.html
formerlyat  www.mcdonalds.com/countries/russia/russia.html
McDonald's Pushkin Square restaurant

Since opening in 1990, McDonald's now operates 79 restaurants in Russia.


Many people in Toronto know that George A. Cohon, who ran McDonald's in Canada, is the one that opened up McDonald's in Russia and serves as Senior Chairman, McDonald's in Russia.

 

Contact made w Ron Christianson, Corporate Communications Manager, McDonald's Restaurants of Canada Limited, June 2005.
Copies of emails kept in the permissions binder.
.
McDonald's in Russia
- some opinions
In the 4th week of Sept 2005, a student in MGTC44, Victoria Zaynullina,  commented that Americans like to think that McDonald's in Russia is identified in the public mind with glasnost and perestroika (policies of openness and restructuring) under Mikhail Gorbachev, but Victoria found tons of negative information and some interesting posters and logos, like the one featured to the left.
Victoria says 

"In fact, Mcdonald's is a symbol of America and capitalism at its worst in the minds of many Russians. When war in Iraq started somebody wrote on the walls of McDonald's in Moscow: "Peace to Iraq, war to McDonalds".


pic supplied by Victoria

In some texts there is mention that nominal exchange rates (rates adjusted for inflation) are not often a good indicator of the international differences between economies. It is explained that there is a disparate price of a Big Mac in Russia and the U.S.A. This difficulty (and the use of comparing Big Macs) became well known among international business people so it was decided that a serious discussion could be made using the Big Mac - therefore the origins of the Hamburger Standard.
.
The Economist magazine took up the challenge and for several years produced a chart showing the price of a Big Mac in the countries of the world.
A simplisitic version of the chart is reproduced below.
 
 
Country
BigMac Price
in Local Currency
in US dollars
United States $2.43
-
Argentina Peso 2.50
1.03
Brazil Real2.95
1.21
Britain £1.90
0.78
Canada C$2.99
1.23
China Yuan9.90
4.07
Euro area €2.52
0.97
France FFr17.50
7.20
Germany DM 4.95
2.04
Hong Kong HK$10.2
4.20
Indonesia Rupiah14,500
5,967
Japan ¥294
121
Mexico Peso19.9
8.19
Russia Rouble33.50
13.79
Singapore s$3.20
1.32
South Korea Won3,000
1,235
Switzerland SFr5.90
2.43
Taiwan NT$70.0
28.8

When last checked in June 2005, this website www.oanda.comstill had a version of the chart for viewing
 http://www.oanda.com/products/bigmac/bigmac.shtml
(MGTC44 students are provided this info FYI, you are not expected to be tested on this)

GDP/GNP - Gross Domestic Product / Gross National Product
GNP/capita - a useful, or not useful measurement -
"The World Bank uses GNP/capita as a basis for its lending policies"

The purpose of economic analysis -
"The purpose of economic analysis is first to appraise the overall outlook of the economy and then assess the impact of economic changes on the firm"
 
 
economic analysis in a management context The purpose, or reason, for developing an economic analysis of a region or specific country, is directly related to the ability to subsequently make managements decisions about whether to do, or not do certain business things in that country or with that country.

So when you are gathering information, according to the headings on the list below, it is important to keep in mind that you don't just collect any information, you collect information which is useful in the context of allowing you to make a decision - otherwise it is useless information and simply costs you time and money.
 

Terms used to describe economic circumstances for measuring business potential

economic analysis in a management context When you gather information, according to the above headings, keep in mind, the
"So what" factor,*
meaning

So what if 71% of the people have cell phones, 
- how does knowing this help me make a decision about my company's product colour, shape, pricing, promotional mix, distribution etc.

* attributed to Prof. Michael Jalland, Rotman (as recalled by Prof. James Davidson of Seneca College)

.
 
economic 
indicators

Income
Distribution

This chart from  
 globalpolicy.igc.org 

data from UNDP 1992, p. 34; 1994 p. 35

from  http://globalpolicy.igc.org/socecon/inequal/inctab.htm 
 
(photo - Sudan, 1993)
Pulitzer winner Kevin Carter

Reasons we should be concerned about inequitable distribution of income

  • effect on consumption trends
  • increased risk of violence and terrorism on a national and int'l scale
  • compassion:- in some religions and cultures it is simply wrong for a few people to be very rich and a lot of people to be very poor
WTGR
..
economic 
indicators

GOLD

This little chart from  www.galmarley.com shows how gold has steadily risen from the $250 level in the first year of the millenium to over $700 an ounce in mid 2007
The reason why gold rises and falls in value is extremely complicated and some analysts run very complicated mathematical modules to try and predict the movements which might allow people to make money on the precious metals market - the bottom line is people still think it is a valuable thing to possess and the movement of the price of gold per ounce remains an important economic indicator for many regions around the globe.

WTGR

..
economic 
indicators

GOLD's

perceived 

value

It used to be said that when people are fearful, either from threat of war or natural disasters, the price of gold goes up as people loss confidence in the structures of our civilization such as banks, and want to have their wealth in a more tangible form that is 
portable - meaning they can carry it with them if they are a refugee to another country, and 
convertable - meaning they can use it to buy something if the currency of their own country no longer has value.

Portability and covertability have become important for many regions of the world in the early years of the new millenium where there is civil war, nature disasters such as eathquakes and tidal waves and weather extremes such as hurricanes.

WTGR

,
economic 
indicators

Birth
rates
- family sizes


source: U.N. World Population Prospects 2004 as quoted in "Booms, Busts, and Echoes" by David E. Bloom and David Canning on the IMF website 
 www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2006/09/bloom.htm 
qs
economic 
indicators

Birth
rates
- family sizes

"The developing world has seen significant reductions in infant and child mortality over the past 50 years. These gains are primarily the result of improved nutrition, public health interventions related to water and sanitation, and medical advances, such as the use of vaccines and antibiotics."
Bloom and Canning

Consequences of birth rates being higher in less developed regions

  • poorer people increase in number, proportionate to richer people 
    • poor/ rich divide gets worse
  • if "children per woman" drops in poor regions - many positive and negative consequences WTGR
qw
economic 
indicators

Birth
rates
- aging population


source: U.N. World Population Prospects 2004 as quoted in "Booms, Busts, and Echoes" by David E. Bloom and David Canning on the IMF website 
 www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2006/09/bloom.htm 

consequences

  • a labour shortage among the young generation could hurt poor countries who have an aging population but no young workers to do important tasks, nor money for technology to replace workers
q
economic indicators:

education
literacy rates
 
 

Why do you want poorer countries to have a higher level of literacy?
Isn't it better to have a "supply" of uneducated people for cheap labour intensive tasks?

There are over 860 million illiterate people in the world, of whom:

  • 61% come from Bangladesh, China *, India and Pakistan
  • 66% are women
In OECD countries, the proportion of adults with tertiary education qualifications (read college or university) rose from 22% to 45.6% between 1975 and 2002

source:  www.globaleducation.edna.edu.au/globaled/go/pid/27 
source:  www.unesco.org 

China * but, according to UNESCO stats for 2007 leads the world now in the absolute number of university graduates

see http://stats.uis.unesco.org/unesco/TableViewer/document.aspx?ReportId=143&IF_Language=eng 

.
economic indicators:
The 
TRADE SUPLUS
For a country like Canada, that depends so heavily on people buying products we export - products made from our resources, it has been the case for decades that we have an international balance of trade surplus - meaning simply we export more stuff than we import.

What matters to economists, and the people who watch our currency exchange rate changes with other countries, is how the trade surplus continues - meaning does it grow slightly, or contract.

You might think it is a good thing if the trade surplus grows, but one of the concerns is that this may cause inflation

Journalist Greg Quinn of the Bloomberh News was quoted in June 2007 saying
"Widening of Trade Surplus raises fears over inflation"

Quinn says "The Bank of Canada may raise interest rates as soon as July, after government reports showed a wider trade surplus, a fourth month of 33-year-low unemployment, and higher-than-expected home starts."

At the same time the trade surplus is developing larger, you have a situation in Canada in June 2007 where the dollar is reaching a high ratio to the U.S. dollar making it possible for Canadian exporters to receive more money from their exports, at the same time that it is cheaper for importers to bring things in to Canada.

WTGR

.

 .
 
witiger.com
  CONTACT I MAIN PAGE I NEWS GALLERY I E-BIZ SHORTCUTS I INT'L BIZ SHORTCUTS I MKTG&BUSINESS SHORTCUTS I TEACHING SCHEDULE
.
  MISTAKES ITEXTS USED I IMAGES I RANK IDISCLAIMER I STUDENT CONTRIBUTORS I FORMER STUDENTS I
.
.